I did an All Elmo first batch. I'd initially wanted to include Big Bird in the mix but I was so tired at the end of it all (everything was made from scratch, including the icing!), I thought Elmo alone was respectable. These were yummy. The Martha Stewart recipe I followed yielded really dense cupcakes which were still moist after two days in the fridge. I knew I got it right when Kayla looked at the cupcakes and went "Elmo!"
Since the following week was Emily's birthday, I decided to bake her some cupcakes. This time, we went with store-bought icing (I think the homemade one was way better). I stuffed half an Oreo Cookie into Cookie Monster's mouth for added effect. The kids loved it, not so much the health conscious adults...

























